Best When I Work Alternatives for Healthcare (2026)
Clockestra Editorial Team
November 3, 2026

Best When I Work Alternatives for Healthcare (2026)
A home-care agency with 60 caregivers runs shifts around the clock. Every caregiver needs current CPR certification and a valid state license. When a cert lapses and the scheduler doesn't know, the agency is exposed.
They pay $150 per month for When I Work Essentials. It handles the schedule. It doesn't track certifications, so the office manager cross-checks a spreadsheet against the roster every week.
Staying on When I Work: $150/month
When I Work Essentials covers the schedule itself: shifts, swaps, availability, messaging. The agency keeps a separate spreadsheet for certification expiries, and the office manager checks it against the schedule every week. It works until it doesn't: the spreadsheet is only as current as the last time someone updated it, and nobody updates it during a busy week.
This is the real cost of staying. Not the $150, but the weekly manual cross-check and the risk it misses someone.
Shiftboard: ~$180/month plus implementation
Shiftboard is built for this kind of complexity: shift differentials, overtime rules, demand planning, compliance management, healthcare among its core industries. For the agency, it would handle the 24/7 roster and the pay rules properly.
The price starts around $3 per user per month (via third-party comparisons; Shiftboard quotes directly), so roughly $180 for 60 staff. But implementation carries an additional charge, support packages add more, and the buying process is enterprise-grade. For a 60-person agency, that is a lot of overhead for scheduling. Shiftboard fits hospital systems; it overwhelms independent agencies.
Deputy: $300 to $390/month
Deputy Lite at $5 per user costs the agency $300 per month; Core at $6.50 (for auto-scheduling and forecasting) costs $390 (deputy.com/pricing, read November 3, 2026). The compliance tooling is real: labor law compliance on every plan, a biometric kiosk that kills buddy punching.
But Deputy does not track certifications either. The agency would pay double or triple the When I Work bill for compliance depth it only partly uses, and still keep the certification spreadsheet. That is the wrong trade.
Connecteam: ~$53/month
Connecteam's Operations Hub starts at $29 per month for the first 30 users, with additional users at $0.80 each (connecteam.com/pricing, read November 3, 2026). For 60 caregivers, that is about $53 per month for scheduling, GPS time clock, forms, and checklists.
The forms are genuinely useful here: visit checklists and incident reports in the same app as the schedule. But like the others, no certification tracking. The agency saves money and still keeps the spreadsheet.
Clockestra: $120 to $180/month
This is where the spreadsheet dies. On Clockestra Premium ($3 per user per month), certifications are tracked per employee with expiry dates, and the scheduler warns when someone is assigned without a required certification or with an expired one. The 60-person agency pays $180 per month; on Pro ($2/user) without certification tracking, $120.
The rest fits the agency too: recurring availability the scheduler respects (caregivers with fixed availabilities), shift swaps, geofenced clock-ins for home visits, timesheets, bulk CSV staff import. Free for the first 10 employees, no minimum invoice, no $30 floor.
The gaps: no shift differentials (Shiftboard's territory) and no biometric kiosk (Deputy's). Agencies that need those should buy them. Agencies whose actual risk is an expired cert on the schedule get the fix here.
The verdict for this agency
The spreadsheet is the problem, and only two products on this list address it: Shiftboard (overkill at this size) and Clockestra (built for it at $180/month). Everything else is a cheaper or more expensive way to keep doing the manual cross-check.
FAQ
Does When I Work track certifications?
No. Scheduling, time tracking, and messaging only. Certification tracking needs a separate system or a different product.
What is the cheapest option for a 60-person home-care agency?
Connecteam at around $53 per month. Clockestra Pro at $120. Both undercut When I Work Essentials at $150.
Can Clockestra block scheduling someone with an expired certification?
On Premium, the scheduler warns when someone is assigned without a required certification or with an expired one. It flags the assignment for the manager rather than hard-blocking it.