Homebase vs Deputy (2026)

Clockestra Editorial Team

November 3, 2026

Homebase vs Deputy (2026)

Homebase vs Deputy (2026)

Homebase and Deputy sit at opposite ends of the scheduling market. Homebase is the tool a 12-person cafe finds first: free to start, simple, done in an afternoon. Deputy is the tool a 150-person operation with auditors buys: compliance depth, biometric kiosks, SSO. Comparing them is useful for one reason: knowing which end you are on.

Pricing, from the source pages

Homebase prices per location per month (pricing page, verified November 2026):

| Plan | Monthly | Annual (per month) | Fits | |---|---|---|---| | Basic | $0 | $0 | 1 location, up to 10 employees | | Essentials | $30 | $24 | Unlimited employees, GPS clock-ins, time tracking | | Plus | $70 | $56 | PTO, blackout dates, advanced scheduling | | All-in-One | $120 | $96 | Payroll-ready, HR advisors, compliance |

Homebase sells payroll at $49 per month plus $6 per employee paid, on any plan. A 14-day All-in-One trial is available.

Deputy prices per user per month (pricing page, read November 3, 2026):

| Plan | Price (per user/month) | The short version | |---|---|---| | Lite | $5.00 | Basic scheduling, time clock, leave and availability | | Core | $6.50 | Adds auto-scheduling, demand forecasting, wage budgets | | Pro | $9.00 | Adds SSO, location hierarchies, analytics and messaging bundles |

Deputy's monthly plans carry a $30 minimum invoice, and every user counts, including owners and admins. Add-ons: payroll at $8 per user plus a $49 monthly base, HR at $2 per user. A 14-day trial with no credit card is available. Neither product has a permanently free tier beyond Homebase Basic.

The cost gap at real headcounts

A single location with 15 staff: Homebase Essentials costs $30 per month. Deputy Lite costs $75. Deputy is 2.5x the price.

A single location with 40 staff: Homebase Essentials still costs $30. Deputy Lite costs $200. Deputy is nearly 7x.

Three locations with 60 staff: Homebase Essentials costs $90. Deputy Lite costs $300. The per-location model pulls away as headcount grows.

Deputy never wins on price against Homebase. If the comparison were only about cost, there would be no article. The question is what the extra money buys and whether your operation needs it.

What Deputy sells that Homebase does not

Compliance is the core of it. Deputy ships labor law compliance on every plan and advanced compliance on Core, built for businesses operating across jurisdictions with different break rules and overtime thresholds. Homebase's All-in-One tier offers HR advisors and compliance help, but it is guidance, not a compliance engine.

The biometric kiosk matters for high-trust environments. Deputy's face-unlock kiosk on Core and up eliminates buddy punching in a way phone-based clock-ins cannot. Homebase has GPS clock-ins and kiosk mode on paid tiers, but not biometrics.

Enterprise controls round it out: SSO, location hierarchies, pay centers, sandbox environments, and SOC 2 Type 2 posture on Deputy Pro. Homebase does not sell to buyers who ask about SOC 2.

Deputy has also spent over a decade building its integration bench (Xero, Paycor, Gusto) and its own payroll add-on. Homebase integrates broadly too, but its ecosystem is built for small business tools, not enterprise finance stacks.

Where Homebase is enough

For a single-location business under 50 people with straightforward labor rules, Deputy is more tool than the job needs. Homebase Essentials at $30 per month covers scheduling, GPS-verified time tracking, team messaging, and POS connections. The setup takes an afternoon. The staff learns it in minutes.

Homebase's ease of use is its most-mentioned strength across several hundred G2 reviews, and that is not a soft metric. A scheduling tool the team actually uses beats a powerful one they work around. Deputy's configuration surface is real; small teams pay for it twice, once in dollars and once in admin time.

If nobody in your business has ever said the words "labor law compliance" in a meeting, you are a Homebase buyer.

When to move from one to the other

Businesses do outgrow Homebase, and the signals are consistent. You are operating in multiple states or countries with different labor rules. You need SSO because IT requires it. You have had a buddy-punching problem that GPS clock-ins did not solve. Your finance team wants payroll, HR, and scheduling in one audited system.

None of those arrive all at once. The typical path is Homebase for the first few years, then a painful quarter of evaluation when the operation crosses roughly 75 to 100 employees or expands across jurisdictions. Deputy is the most common landing spot because it is the deepest product in this price band, not because it is the cheapest.

Where Clockestra fits

Clockestra takes the per-user model down to a Homebase-like price: free for up to 10 employees, then $2 per user per month on Pro or $3 on Premium, with no minimum invoice. A 40-person team pays $80 per month for geofenced clock-ins, kiosk mode, shift swaps, availability the scheduler respects, timesheets, bulk CSV staff import, and certification tracking with expiry dates on Premium. Deputy Lite costs $200 for the same headcount.

The gaps are Deputy's compliance engine, biometric kiosk, and SSO, and Homebase's $30 flat per-location pricing at scale. Teams that need compliance depth should buy Deputy. Teams that want the cheapest competent scheduling for one location should buy Homebase Essentials. Everyone in between gets more per dollar here.

FAQ

Is Homebase or Deputy cheaper?

Homebase, at every headcount. Per-location pricing beats per-user pricing once you pass a handful of staff, and the gap widens with every hire.

Does Deputy have a free plan?

No. Deputy offers a 14-day trial; the cheapest paid plan is Lite at $5 per user per month with a $30 minimum invoice. Homebase Basic is free for up to 10 employees at one location.

Which is better for a restaurant?

Homebase for most restaurants: cheaper, simpler, POS connections on the free tier. Deputy fits restaurant groups large enough to need compliance tooling and biometric kiosks.

When should a business switch from Homebase to Deputy?

When labor compliance gets complicated (multiple jurisdictions), IT requires SSO, or buddy punching survives GPS clock-ins. Typically around 75 to 100 employees.

Ready to optimize your general scheduling?

Join Clockestra today and start saving hours every week on workforce management.