When I Work vs Deputy (2026)
Clockestra Editorial Team
November 3, 2026

When I Work vs Deputy (2026)
When I Work and Deputy both price per user per month. When I Work starts at $2.50; Deputy starts at $5. The question is what the extra dollars buy, and whether you need what they buy.
The price ladder
When I Work (pricing page, read November 3, 2026):
| Plan | Price (per user/month) | The short version | |---|---|---| | Essentials | $2.50 | Single-location scheduling, auto-scheduling, team messaging | | Pro | $5.00 | Multi-location, labor sharing, scheduling rules | | Premium | $8.00 | Adds API access, webhooks, SAML/SSO |
Deputy (pricing page, read November 3, 2026):
| Plan | Price (per user/month) | The short version | |---|---|---| | Lite | $5.00 | Basic scheduling, time clock, leave and availability | | Core | $6.50 | Adds auto-scheduling, demand forecasting, wage budgets | | Pro | $9.00 | Adds SSO, location hierarchies, analytics and messaging bundles |
Deputy's monthly plans carry a $30 minimum invoice, and every user counts, including owners and admins. Both offer a 14-day trial with no credit card. Neither has a free plan.
Auto-scheduling costs $2.50 on one and $6.50 on the other
The most surprising line in this comparison is that When I Work includes auto-scheduling on its cheapest plan. Deputy gates it behind Core. A 20-person team gets auto-built schedules for $50 per month on When I Work Essentials; the same feature costs $130 on Deputy Core.
This is not a mistake on Deputy's part. Their auto-scheduling sits inside a compliance and labor-optimization stack (wage budgets, demand forecasting, labor law compliance) aimed at operations where a bad schedule is a legal liability, not just an inconvenience. When I Work's version is simpler: fill the shifts, respect availability, done. For most small businesses, the simpler version is the whole job.
What Deputy's premium actually buys
Strip out auto-scheduling and Deputy's case rests on four things.
Compliance depth. Deputy ships labor law compliance on every plan, advanced compliance on Core, built for businesses operating across jurisdictions where break rules and overtime thresholds differ. When I Work does not sell compliance as a feature.
The kiosk. Deputy's biometric kiosk clocking (face unlock, on Core and up) eliminates buddy punching in a way phone apps cannot. High-turnover, high-trust environments like warehousing and healthcare pay for this.
Enterprise posture. SSO, location hierarchies, pay centers, sandbox environments, and SOC 2 Type 2 sit on Deputy Pro. When I Work reserves SSO for its own Premium tier at $8.
The ecosystem. Deputy has spent over a decade building integrations (Xero, Paycor, Gusto) and a payroll add-on of its own. When I Work leans on partners instead, most visibly a Rippling partnership that bundles six free months of payroll and HR.
None of this is marketing fluff, but all of it is aimed at operations above roughly 50 people. Below that, you are paying for depth you will not touch.
Where When I Work wins
Price is the obvious one, and it is decisive at small headcounts. A 15-person team pays $37.50 per month on When I Work Essentials versus $75 on Deputy Lite, and gets auto-scheduling thrown in. Deputy cannot close that gap without discounting.
Multi-location at $5 is the quieter win. When I Work Pro covers multiple locations, labor sharing across sites, and scheduling rules for the same per-user price as Deputy Lite, which is single-location basic scheduling. A three-shop retail group gets more from When I Work Pro than from Deputy Lite at identical spend.
Simplicity counts too. When I Work's pitch is setup in minutes, and its review base (4.5 across 1,230+ ratings on its own site) skews toward small businesses that never needed a workforce platform. Deputy's power comes with configuration surface; When I Work's comes without it.
Where Clockestra fits
Clockestra undercuts both on price and skips the minimums: free for up to 10 employees, then $2 per user per month on Pro or $3 on Premium, no $30 floor. A 15-person team pays $30 per month for geofenced clock-ins, kiosk mode, shift swaps, availability the scheduler respects, timesheets, and bulk CSV staff import. When I Work Essentials costs $37.50 for the same team; Deputy Lite costs $75.
The gaps are Deputy's compliance stack, biometric kiosk, and SSO, and When I Work's multi-location labor sharing. Teams that need those should pay for them. The rest get the same scheduling and verified clock-ins for less.
FAQ
Is When I Work or Deputy cheaper?
When I Work, by roughly half at comparable tiers: Essentials at $2.50 undercuts Deputy Lite at $5, and When I Work Pro at $5 matches Deputy Lite's price with multi-location scheduling included.
Does When I Work have auto-scheduling?
Yes, on the $2.50 Essentials plan. Deputy requires Core at $6.50 for its version, which is built for compliance-heavy operations.
What is Deputy's minimum monthly cost?
$30 per month on monthly Lite, Core, or Pro plans, per Deputy's FAQ. When I Work has no minimum invoice.
Which is better for multi-location businesses?
When I Work Pro at $5 per user covers multi-location scheduling and labor sharing. Deputy handles multi-location through hierarchies on Pro at $9, aimed at larger operations.